15 anos ajudando empresas brasileiras
a escolherem o melhor software

Avaliações do Ellucian Banner

Sobre Ellucian Banner

Software de ERP que permite às instituições de ensino superior gerenciar todos os processos financeiros e supervisionar o orçamento e as atividades relacionadas a doações.

Saiba mais sobre o Ellucian Banner

Vantagens:

We use it to keep track of employee records. My main use is budget and creating purchase requisitions.

Desvantagens:

The Banner 9 integration seems to make transitioning between forms sluggish.

Notas do Ellucian Banner

Pontuação média

Praticidade
3,1
Atendimento ao cliente
3,2
Recursos
3,6
Relação qualidade/preço
3,1

Probabilidade de recomendação

5,9/10

O Ellucian Banner tem uma classificação geral de 3,7 em 5 estrelas com base em 39 avaliações de usuários no Capterra.

Filtrar avaliações (39)

Classificar por

Você já usou o Ellucian Banner antes?

Compartilhe suas experiências com outros compradores de software.

Filtrar avaliações (39)

Ryan
Ryan
Accountant - Internal Controls, EUA
Usuário do LinkedIn Verificado
Educação superior, 1.001–5.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

I use this software every day for my accounting job at a major Midwest university.

5,0 há 6 anos

Comentários: This software has allowed me to be very efficient with my work as I am able to identify any accounting issues that may arise. Additionally, the system makes it very easy to look at prior fiscal years, which is a very large benefit when our auditors are asking for that information.

Vantagens:

This software, and the newest update, has made accounting a breeze. The financial system allows me to easily see where any reconciling item may be, and allows me reference codes so I may gather further detail. The new capability of using Chrome is a great feature as well because our entire organization is comfortable with the format.

Desvantagens:

My only con would be that on some screens I am not able to copy certain data, which requires me to manually input the data. This is a small complaint because it is minimal amounts of typing.

Christian
Talent Acquisition Specialist, República Dominicana
Terceirização/Deslocalização, 501–1.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de um ano
Fonte da avaliação

The best platform to manage employees data.

5,0 há 4 meses

Vantagens:

This program provides a centralized database for storing all employee-related information, including personal details, employment history, benefits, payroll information, and performance evaluations. This centralized approach streamlines HR processes and ensures data consistency across the institution.

Desvantagens:

The initial investment and ongoing costs associated with Ellucian Banner, including licensing fees, implementation services, maintenance, and support, can be significant. The fact that they don't provide a free trial can play against the small businesses.

Carl
Director of Enterprise Integrations, EUA
Gestão da educação, 10.000+ funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Alternativas consideradas anteriormente:

Candid Review from a Prior Fan

3,0 há 11 meses

Vantagens:

Ellucian Banner was a single solution for all our primary university functions. At the pricing secured in 2005, it remains an incredibly high value product in the growing list of software tools used by Utah State University.

Desvantagens:

Ellucian's technology maturity has been an incredibly bumpy road. There have been incredible wins like the Banner 9 Student Registration system. There has also been some major let downs such as the Higher Education Data Model and nearly incomprehensible Ethos API offering. The loss of Ellucian Customer Service Managers who were assigned to look out for and advocate on behalf of customers has perhaps been the biggest loss experienced by any software by any vendor. The rate at which Ellucian has changed their online community platform has been mind boggling and the loss of access to previous efforts by customers on each platform is huge. Ideas has finally been replaced, but most customers are already of the mindset that it's just another tool where great recommendations for product enhancements go to die.

Nicole
Degree Analyst, EUA
Gestão da educação, 1.001–5.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Degree evaluation

4,0 há 10 meses

Vantagens:

Students degree evaluation - really my comment is to short. lol... I like pretty much everything with Ellucian

Desvantagens:

Our help guide isn't up to date with the new verse so sometimes going to the guide to figure out what you did wrong and why something will not save/update is a pain. But, I can usually figure out what I did.

Avaliador Verificado
Usuário do LinkedIn Verificado
Educação superior, 501–1.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Expensive and old-fashioned

4,0 há 6 anos

Comentários: It is a complete solution for a university management system.

Vantagens:

One thing you can say about Banner Finance is that it is complete. It can handle whatever a university throws at it.

Desvantagens:

The interface is still forms-based, just like in the 1970s. There is a newer web-based interface, but it is just a webified version of the old forms. It could have been much better, but they are married to 50-year-old paradigms.

Kala
Scholarship & Administrative Coordinator, EUA
Gestão da educação, 2–10 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Decent user experience

3,0 há 5 anos

Vantagens:

The updates that came with Banner 9 have made it much more user-friendly, although there's still a long way to go in this department. It has become much easier to search for various Banner forms, a feature that was lacking in previous iterations of Banner. The overall look is sleeker than the previous version and navigation within the forms has been made somewhat simpler with the reorganization of the page and inclusion of tool dropdowns.

Desvantagens:

Occasional glitches disrupt the daily workflow. Many processes are still not as intuitive as they could be, especially when it comes to entering multiple invoices with separate FOAPAL strings. There is some difficulty getting Banner to talk to other software programs. While exporting data is easier than in previous versions of Banner, some print screen attempts go better than others.

Avaliador Verificado
Usuário do LinkedIn Verificado
Educação superior, 201–500 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Programmer / Helpdesk POV

3,0 há 11 meses

Comentários: ActionLine support has great subject matter experts(SME) and support. Cloud team seems to be lacking SMEs and doesn't seem to fully understand how all the modules relate.

Vantagens:

I am allowed to see all the DB, and make custom items. Shell jobs, Oracle Packages, Oracle Jobs, and they are coming out with improved interface coding by moving to GraphQL and React JS.

Desvantagens:

The cloud team is consistent about missing deadlines. Cloud support is very disorganized. Communication from cloud techs to customers is very poor, black box.

Andrew
Financial Aid, EUA
Gestão da educação, 201–500 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Was a great product, not so much anymore.

2,0 há 11 meses

Comentários: Banner used to be great. Good support and a quality product but now there seem to be defects with every release and the move to the cloud has been a disaster. Things that used to take a few days now take weeks and we are constantly having to align with Ellucians timetables instead of them adapting to ours, the customer.

Vantagens:

It does most of the financial aid processes we need it to do.

Desvantagens:

The customer service/support is awful. Maybe it's our cloud team but there are constant mistakes and delays to the point we are considering another SIS.

Tasneem
Associate professor, Arábia Saudita
Educação superior, 1.001–5.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Best administrative software application to store data and manage users.

5,0 há 7 meses

Vantagens:

1. User friendly. 2. Easy to execute and navigate the dashboard. 3. Excellent student database management system. 4. Grade entry made easy and customized as per the specifications. 5. Ellucian Banner faculty has features like students attendance tracking, class list approval, academic profile and detailed schedule making it easy to follow-up under one roof. 6. All data is secure.

Desvantagens:

1. Report customization is difficult. 2. Restricted capabilities.

Demetris
Senior Accountant, EUA
Educação superior, 501–1.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: 6 a 12 meses
Fonte da avaliação

Banner Review

3,0 há 11 meses

Vantagens:

I was not involved in that process or I guess I'm not sure what I like best. Well, the S.O.S. page is nice and it's easier to perform journal vouchers usinig S.O.S.

Desvantagens:

The fixed asset module is difficult to navigate and impute assets especially the accessories or parts that are less than $5K. There are too many steps involved to get these items capitalized and attached to the main asset.

Nick
Director, Enterprise Applications, EUA
Educação superior, 1.001–5.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Legacy Software That Has Not Been Modernized

1,0 há 11 meses

Vantagens:

The only positive aspect of Banner is that it has a decent Student Information System.

Desvantagens:

Nearly everything. To begin, the interface has not been modernized to current application standards. The term "lipstick on a pig" applies more to Banner than almost any other application I have ever come across.They do not seem to care about making the ERP side of their product function well. They have focused most on the SIS side, which is understandable, but the lack of functionality on the ERP side means it is basically useless for a modern campus. It is only working for half of the business.Their reporting functionality is poor and bordering on non-existent.For IT, this product is a nightmare. The releases are extremely difficult to install and maintain. The codebase is locked in 20 years in the past. They still use 8 character table names!!! The amount of technical debt means if you even wanted to deploy it as a SaaS product, it is nearly impossible, let alone trying to put it up in the cloud.In short, the company seems to be resting on their laurels as the market leader and they are falling far behind the competition.

Georgiana
Accountant, EUA
Educação superior, 201–500 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Banner Finance and related Ellucian products

4,0 há 11 meses

Comentários: Ellucian is a robust computer system. Data does not get lost unexpectedly. There are exception reports that allow us to keep the financial records in balance and control reports that allow us to keep the subsidiary ledgers in agreement with the control accounts.

Vantagens:

Implementing software systems is difficult but we had some excellent trainers when we went live with Banner Finance. The Ellucian support is very comprehensive. The various modules interface with Finance which eliminates duplicate data entry. And the current Banner product can be accessed from anywhere.

Desvantagens:

The length of the fields in Banner 9 data entry pages do not correspond to the data being entered. I shouldn't have to scroll to see what I have typed into a single field. There are often huge spaces but only a limited number of characters are accepted and the rest are truncated.

Tara
Financial Aid Counselor, EUA
Serviços financeiros, 11–50 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Financial Aid User

4,0 há 5 anos

Vantagens:

Ellucian Banner is the platform that I have used at my previous and current university, while working in financial aid. I have only ever used Banner so I do not have another platform to compare it to. This system has been very beneficial in automating the processing for financial aid. I have used this program for over 7 years. All student, and employee, related information is stored in one location and necessary processing can be handled with Banner. Financially and academic based, this program has helped be the "one-stop-shop" for all information for our large student base. Banner 9 has made the screens easier to use for new users (due to acronyms) but Banner 8 was the most efficient program I have ran.

Desvantagens:

Banner 9 seems to have a lag between screens that has not yet been improved. Being web-based, it has really slowed down or processing. There are glitches that are quickly fixed but there seems to be more issues with this new Banner program than what we ever dealt with while using Banner 8.

Jonathan
Administrative Systems Support Technician, EUA
Gestão da educação, 201–500 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

IBM for Higher Education

3,0 há 11 meses

Comentários: It is our system of record, the main database tied to everything on campus.

Vantagens:

ERP software is never quick or easy to implement but most people in higher education use this package so it is very well known in the industry.

Desvantagens:

It is old and has the baggage of any old system and lots of training is needed for employees new to it.

Justin
Senior Financial Analsyt, EUA
Educação superior, 1.001–5.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Banner Finance - A Highly Functional Financial Tool for Higher Education

4,0 há 5 anos

Comentários: Our overall experience with Banner Finance has been very positive. We are able to generate quarterly and annual financial reports that our auditors and finance staff can work with and drill down on to get detail behind the figures.

Vantagens:

Banner Finance offers a lot of great functionality but what I liked most about the finance platform was its ability to interface between six campuses with Banner Student to communicate tuition payments and student receivables with our system financial system and update all as though they were one.

Desvantagens:

Because this financial platform is so big, when we have experienced problems with Banner, it has caused debilitating shutdowns that grind our finance and accoutning system to a halt and users are on standby until we can get traffic started again.

Joseph
Instructional Designer, EUA
Gestão da educação, 1.001–5.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Tries to do more than it can

3,0 semana passada Novo

Comentários: The people at Ellucian are professional and direct. Their systems are . . . neither. Their Course Catalog system lacks keyword searching - a problem they acknowledge but cannot solve. Their SIS will not provide real-time updates to our LMS - a problem they acknowledge but cannot solve, despite the existence of 3rd party solutions that do the job.

Vantagens:

It brought together many disparate systems, saving a tremendous amount of time.

Desvantagens:

The company promises more than it can deliver, and attempts to integrate into multiple systems it should not.

Jacqui
Manager, EUA
Gestão da educação, 10.000+ funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

As a user can be frustrating

3,0 há 5 anos

Comentários: Overall I can't picture doing my job without Banner Finance, however, it can be a source of frustration too. But in the end it really is a powerful tool if you know how to use it.

Vantagens:

As a person who uses this for work, only as a user (not an administrator) it is nice to have everything in one place and all info is presented clearly and as is. Sometimes you do need to take a few minutes or a few steps to get what you need, but its all there.

Desvantagens:

Transitioning from the last version to the latest has been cumbersome and challenging. Also, knowing the shortcuts for all forms can be like learning a new language.

Gabrielle
Administrative Assistant, EUA
Gestão da educação, 1.001–5.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Banner

4,0 há 4 anos

Comentários: Banner is really difficult to use. Especially if you don't receive formal training, it isn't intuitive like some softwares. We really struggle each time we need to do something in Banner, and we have written instructions for everything in case we forget a step.

Vantagens:

It has a lot of different features, which is nice, but we don't really know how to use them because the interface isn't intuitive.

Desvantagens:

It's hard to know what you are doing, and it's very easy to make a mistake that could do a fair bit of damage.

Greg
Application Developer and System Admin, EUA
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Unified ERP designed specifically for higher-ed

3,0 há 6 anos

Vantagens:

Focused for higher education application. Provides fully integrated, unified database system built on Oracle platform with modules for accounting, Human Resources , financial aid, Advancement, and all aspects of student management from recruitment to admissions through to graduation and alumni relations.

Desvantagens:

Very expensive, not particularly user-friendly or intuitive, high-cost maintenance agreements, not best-in-class in any area.

Justin
Accounts Payable Analyst, EUA
Educação superior, 5.001–10.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Banner Finance - Higher Education Focus

4,0 há 6 anos

Comentários: Banner Finance allows our AP team to pull vendor data quickly and to export that information for closer review. Vendor management is a huge selling point for this software!

Vantagens:

Banner Finance forms allow users to export into excel, which makes research easy. The vast array of available forms provide almost any data across the organization. The form search features are excellent as well!

Desvantagens:

The Banner 9 integration seems to make transitioning between forms sluggish.

Rachel
Program Manager, EUA
Gestão da educação, 501–1.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Banner is outdated and not super efficient

3,0 há 5 anos

Vantagens:

The ease of navigating through multiple screens and whether or not vendors have been paid along with check dates/check numbers made it easy to relay information back to our vendors in terms on payment.

Desvantagens:

Memorization of banner codes used for each banner screen can sometimes become overwhelming and inefficient.

Rhonda
Facilities & Housing Coordinator, EUA
Educação superior, 501–1.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Easy to Use for Budgeting

5,0 ano passado

Vantagens:

The college uses Ellucian Banner for all kinds of things. We use it to keep track of employee records. My main use is budget and creating purchase requisitions. I also use it with WebTMA to integrate charges from the work orders to charge the other departments.

Desvantagens:

My only issue with Ellucian banner is permissions are very restrictive so you have to be granted permission to a lot of different screens.

Justin
Management Analyst, EUA
Educação superior, 5.001–10.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Strong ERP, weak UI

5,0 há 5 anos

Vantagens:

Customization of user dashboard allows for quick access to each Banner form that you use on a regular basis. The hotkey shortcuts for this software are an absolute must

Desvantagens:

Banner 9.0 helped alleviate some of this issue, but the UI is a bit clunky and feels dated.

Avaliador Verificado
Usuário do LinkedIn Verificado
Educação superior, 1.001–5.000 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Banner Finance Review

5,0 há 5 anos

Vantagens:

Amazing application with many features and modules. Banner Finance in particular is the industry leading software. Great community with exceptional services.

Desvantagens:

Can be a little cumbersome and very little to no customization.

Cortney
Hrc, EUA
Educação superior, 51–200 funcionários
Usou o software para: Mais de dois anos
Fonte da avaliação

Banner is amazing

5,0 há 3 anos

Vantagens:

This product is great for making sure policies are compliant by allowing financial information to flow seemingly through our company

Desvantagens:

I love this product. I really have no complaints